Alternatively, you can dilute it with a little water and pour it over meat and vegetables. Home » By Cooking Style » 30 Minutes or Less Recipes » The Best Cocktail Sauce Ever. Sharp horseradish flavor, offering lots of heat, Sold with St. Elmo’s Steak House Seasoning, Beefy flavor, making it an excellent cocktail sauce for meat, An original recipe from Johnny’s Seattle restaurant, Uses ingredients such as red wine vinegar and tomato paste, Made with fresh vine-ripened California tomatoes, Versatile enough for pairing with foods like french fries and onion rings, Mild, tomato-based flavor with a hint of horseradish, Specks of white or fuzz on the surface, showing signs of mold. It's just not a shrimp cocktail without the cocktail sauce. Therefore, it makes a perfect gift for spicy cocktail sauce lovers. Agave nectar and cane sugar offer a touch of sweetness without the use of high-fructose corn syrup. They use fresh California tomatoes ripened right on the vine. Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce’s roots are in Seattle. Tabasco sauce and horseradish are the two ingredients that contribute to cocktail sauce’s spicy, hot flavor. It comes in an 8-ounce jar and is on par with the prices of Old Original Bookbinder’s cocktail sauce, but don’t let its smaller size fool you. After much trial and error testing different spice combinations, in 1940, Johnny Meaker opened up Crawford’s Sea Grill. This familiar red condiment is a popular side for all sorts of seafood, and is enjoyed across the globe. Just don’t be surprised if you become addicted to it! A unique ingredient in Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce is tamarind, a sour pulp around seeds that grow on trees in Africa and other tropical areas. Seafood specialist Old Bay is another good cocktail sauce featured on this list. As you’ll learn in our FAQ section, cocktail sauce’s use goes beyond shrimp and seafood. Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce comes as a concentrated form. What companies will you find on this list of the best cocktail sauce brands? Lists of your favorite things to stuff in your face, ranked. Standout Features of St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce: Best for: People who love meat and want a beefy flavor in their cocktail sauce for dishes such as meatloaf. St. Elmo recommends storing their cocktail sauce in the refrigerator to maintain its spicy flavor. Home » Grocery » Sauce » Best Store Bought Cocktail Sauce Brand. Lovers of mild to medium cocktail sauces will be pleased that Old Original Bookbinder uses just the right amount of fresh horseradish and spices to give the sauce a little kick without it landing too hot on the tongue. Cocktail Sauce Dipping Cup - … Those other blends of spices will depend on the maker. It isn’t the cheapest cocktail sauce on the market, but there are plenty of pricier (and smaller) jars of cocktail sauce out there. Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce is ideal for people looking for a mild, multi-purpose sauce. Cocktail sauce is most commonly paired with shrimp, but its uses extend far beyond this for creative cooks. Standout Features of Old Original Bookbinder: Best for: Lovers of spicy cocktail sauce. Best Store Bought Cocktail Sauce Brand. What companies will you find on this list of the best cocktail sauce … Crosse & Blackwell sells their cocktail sauce in a 12-ounce glass jar. Use this flavorful bottle to season up meat, seafood, and vegetables. A Cocktail sauce does go bad, so it’s essential to check the expiration date. An opened can of shrimp cocktail sauce lasts approximately six to nine months in the fridge. Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce is 100% made in the USA and is gluten-free. It isn’t necessary to refrigerate an unopened can of cocktail sauce. Updated 1 Oct 2018 2.3k votes 1.0k voters 26.0k views19 items. The Best Cocktail Sauce Brands. Sour Cream Dip – great for a potluck; Sausage Cheese Dip – with spicy Italian sausage; The Best … Therefore, you should learn what to look out for to tell if your cocktail sauce is terrible. The cocktail sauce can either be used with other condiments or enjoyed directly out of the bottle. And you’re in good company—according to Tastewise, there’s been a nearly 84% increase in cocktail sauce consumption since August 2019. However, some brands include touches of other ingredients for a unique taste. Cocktail sauce is great for shrimp cocktail and scallops but also tastes great as a zesty dip.. Use for fries, or even as a topping for scrambled eggs or really anything that needs an extra punch of flavor!. The price point for St. Elmo Shrimp Elmo Cocktail Sauce edges towards the higher end of the shrimp cocktail spectrum.